Article
The Self-Reliance Curve

Leadership mode: when you are a tour guide and when a backpack

Raymond Honings 5 November 2025
Two teams from different work styles learning to collaborate in China after an acquisition.
Summary

A team does not need one leadership style but a leader who can switch modes. The tour guide organises the route and schedules the moments, the backpack leaves room to choose along the way. Under pressure almost everyone falls back on whichever mode feels most familiar, and that derails the instant the situation asks for the opposite. In a merger in China two working styles collided: one saw recklessness, the other bureaucracy.

Key Insights
  • Sometimes a team needs a guided tour: clear plans, fixed routes. Sometimes a backpack: room to explore and adjust along the way. The mistake is forcing one form where the other fits.
  • The turning point rarely sits in a better method. It sits in two questions that turn tension into information: what are you afraid of and what do you hope will happen.
  • Agility in multicultural teams is not about structure or freedom. It is about structure that makes freedom possible. Both rhythms need each other to carry progress.

Sometimes leadership is a tour organiser. Sometimes it is a backpack.

Two leadership modes

A team does not need one leadership style. It needs a leader who can switch between modes as the situation asks. The tour guide mode organises: map the route, plan moments, get people on time to the right place. The backpack mode leaves room: choose along the way, do not lock everything in advance, trust the experience of the group.

Most leaders have a natural preference for one of the two. Under pressure almost everyone falls back on the style that feels most familiar. That works as long as the situation matches that style. It derails the moment the situation asks for the exact opposite.

An acquisition in China

A dear colleague once told me about a project in China. He was asked to merge two teams after an acquisition. The gap was enormous.

An acquisition is almost never only legal or financial. It is an encounter between two organisational cultures, often with very different histories behind them. One culture has relied for years on procedures, the other on instinct. One has learned to make mistakes through documentation, the other through experiments. Neither style is wrong by definition. But the friction on day one is large.

Two styles, one conflict

One group worked carefully: prepare first, document everything, follow the rules. The other moved fast: let's try it and see what happens.

You can imagine the conflict. One side saw the other as reckless. The other side saw them as slow and bureaucratic.

Both judgements were understandable from their own experience. And both were unhelpful from the reality of the merged team. What was efficient in a homogeneous context became a blockage in this new context. Not because one of the styles stopped working, but because they began to work against each other the moment they sat in the same room.

Two questions that changed everything

The turning point came when the colleague asked both groups two simple questions. 'What are you afraid of?' And 'What do you hope will happen?'

No problem-solving questions. No questions that ask for an action plan. Questions that made the tension around the acquisition explicit. What was being turned into judgement in silence, became information out loud.

Tension rarely disappears by being solved. It disappears by being made audible in a way that is not an accusation.

While the structured group explained how complex the import laws were, the creative team began to listen. And when the creatives shared their energy and ideas, the careful group began to see their value.

When the metaphor clicks

That is the moment the metaphor clicked. Sometimes you need a guided tour, clear plans, fixed routes. Sometimes you need a backpack, room to explore and adjust along the way.

Progress, after all, does not always follow the same route. Sometimes it needs a different rhythm.

For the merged team it meant they no longer had to choose between 'structured' and 'creative'. Both were needed all the time, but at different moments and for different kinds of work. The role of the leader shifted from conflict mediator to director making explicit which mode was up at which time.

What agility actually means

This is what agility actually means in multicultural teams: cross-functional, iterative and built on respect for different rhythms.

It is not about structure or freedom. It is about structure that makes freedom possible.

Many organisations talk about agility as a property of the team. In practice it is a property of the system that carries the team. Anyone who designs the system to carry multiple rhythms side by side gets an agile team. Anyone who only asks agility from the team without adjusting the system gets an exhausted team.

Rhythm and trust over perfect plans

I see the same balance reappearing in global teams, where trust and rhythm count more than perfect plans.

As Lynda Gratton reminds us: the future of work is not about choosing one side, but about designing systems where both can thrive.

The question for the leader is then no longer 'which style fits me'. The question is 'which mode does this team need right now, and which mode follows in two weeks'. Anyone who asks that question weekly stays switchable. Anyone who never asks it implicitly tells their team there is only one good way, and that everyone else has to adapt to it. Both signals are remembered, long after the leader themselves has forgotten them.

A Take-Home Message

Sometimes you need a guided tour, sometimes a backpack. It is not about structure or freedom.

It is about structure that makes freedom possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do you mean by 'leadership as tour guide versus backpack'? +
A tour organiser provides a pre-mapped route, with fixed moments, shared times and clear expectations. For some teams that is exactly what they need to move forward with confidence. A backpack provides room to choose along the way, the moment reality calls for adjustment. For other teams that is exactly what they need to deliver. Both forms are legitimate. The mistake sits in forcing the one where the other fits.
Which two questions work for tense teams after an acquisition? +
'What are you afraid of?' and 'What do you hope will happen?'. Two questions that ask for no solutions, but translate the tension into information. When both groups answer in turn after an acquisition, they usually discover that their concerns are not incompatible. That the so-called other side also has something to lose, and something to hope for. That the other style served a function not yet visible. From that moment on the conversation tips.
Why does progress run on a different rhythm in every team? +
Because progress is not the same as speed. A structured team makes progress by mapping risks in advance and taking steps whose consequences are surveyable. An exploratory team makes progress by learning quickly and adjusting on new information. Both produce results, but via different cycles. Anyone who forces them onto the same rhythm often destroys the power of both.
What is structure that makes freedom possible? +
A minimum of agreements that is large enough to carry trust, and small enough to keep adjustment possible. Weekly check-ins that run alongside experimental work. Clear decision-making lines that do not make every decision themselves. Shared definitions of progress that leave room for different paths to it. Structure that gets in the way of freedom can be recognised by how often the team has to negotiate to be able to do something. Structure that makes freedom possible can be recognised by how rarely they have to.
What does Lynda Gratton say about this tension? +
The work of Lynda Gratton on the future of work emphasises that organisations do not have to choose between structure and autonomy. Both can be designed to strengthen each other, instead of constraining each other. For multicultural teams this is especially relevant, because different cultures have different preferences for how structure and freedom are balanced. A well-designed system asks for no cultural adaptation, it lets the variants exist side by side.
Raymond Honings
About the author

Raymond Honings

Raymond is the founder of Seemotion. He works with managers and leadership teams across cultures, helping them build self-reliant teams that perform under pressure. Over the past years he has worked with more than 1,000 managers worldwide. Today most of his work takes place in Asia, mainly in Korea, Taiwan, China and Japan.