Article
The Self-Reliance Curve

Tribal belonging: where leaders find their team

Raymond Honings 15 October 2025
Tribal belonging: managers coaching each other as a peer team instead of figuring out the role in isolation.
Summary

Most new managers never ask out loud where they belong, yet that quiet question sits underneath almost every doubt in their first year. A promotion changes someone's social position within a day, the old team falls away and a new one rarely takes its place. Treat managers therefore not as separate role holders but as a peer team, with peer coaching groups, thematic sessions and buddy systems. A simple structure like Sir John Whitmore's GROW model creates movement in thirty minutes, and what works well above becomes visible below.

Key Insights
  • Anyone promoted into management loses a team and rarely gets a new one in return. That quiet in-between space explains why so many leaders struggle in their first year, often without anyone noticing.
  • Together, managers are the most underused team in the organisation. Treat them as a peer team rather than as separate role holders, and the entire management layer starts to operate differently.
  • Sir John Whitmore's GROW model gives managers a simple structure to coach each other. No vague conversations, but a focused dialogue that creates movement in thirty minutes.

Where do I belong? The quiet question most managers never ask out loud, and that nevertheless sits underneath almost every doubt in their first year as a leader.

It is a question I ignored for years. I assumed I did not belong because I was not yet good enough. Only later did I understand that the problem was not in me, but in the structure I had stepped into.

The quiet question no one asks

Managers talk about targets, planning, escalations and stakeholders. Almost never about where they themselves belong. The question feels too personal for the boardroom and too heavy for the corridor. So it stays unasked, and the answer stays absent.

The result is an entire layer in the organisation in which people are simultaneously responsible and lonely. Responsible for the team below them. Lonely in relation to everyone outside it. A combination that no one sustains long term without damage.

The promotion that makes you lonely

When I was first promoted into a management role at Seemotion, I felt alone. I had been part of the team, and suddenly I was not. Even former colleagues looked at me differently. Jokes shifted in tone. Conversations stopped when I joined, or suddenly turned more polite. None of it was meant unkindly. It was simply the consequence of a shifted role.

What surprised me most at the time was how poorly prepared I was for it. I had had a good conversation about responsibilities, about targets and about reporting lines. I had not had a single conversation about how it would feel to fall out of the old nest without yet having a new one.

It felt as if I had to figure everything out and solve it on my own. Not because anyone asked me to, but because I saw no one I could ask.

I now see that pattern in nearly every new manager I work with. Not as a weakness, but as a side effect of how organisations design promotions. The substance of the role is handed over, the social repositioning is skipped.

A coffee that changed everything

Until one day a senior manager invited me for coffee. No agenda. No checklist. Just a sincere question: how are you doing?

That moment changed more than I could see at the time. Not because of the tip I received, because I did not receive one. But because of what it implied. Someone considered me part of a group I had until that point only seen as colleagues.

I realised I was not alone. I simply had a different kind of team. My fellow managers. Until then I had seen them as people who happened to sit in the same meetings. From that moment on I saw them as peers. People who carried the same kind of questions, the same dilemmas, the same quiet uncertainty.

Managers as a team, not as separate role holders

Most organisations treat their managers as individual role holders. Each manager reports separately, gets targets separately, holds performance reviews separately. The management layer is a group on paper, but in practice a collection of solo players who happen to share a floor.

There is an operational cost in that which is rarely named. Every manager solves the same questions over again. Every manager makes the same learning mistakes. Every manager feels alone, on a Thursday afternoon at four o'clock, in a question to which a colleague two doors down already has an answer.

When you start treating managers as a team, that dynamic shifts. Not because the roles change, but because the channel through which learning and support flow changes. A question that was processed alone is now shared. A pattern that was previously invisible becomes visible because three colleagues recognise it.

That is why it is so powerful to organise managers explicitly as a peer team. A network where they support, challenge and learn from each other.

Three structures that make the difference

It does not need to be complicated. A few simple structures already make a big difference.

Peer coaching groups. Short, fixed sessions in which managers coach each other through a clear process. One participant brings in a question, the group helps via a fixed structure. No dumping advice, no offering solutions before the question is sharp. Just focused inquiry until the person bringing in the case sees their own next step.

Thematic sessions. Gatherings around a shared question: team dynamics, strategic decisions, dealing with escalations, hard conversations. Not training, but collegial exchange in which practice and theory alternate. The strength lies in the shared context. Five managers in the same organisation see the same pattern from five different positions.

Buddy systems. A senior manager is paired with a junior manager, not to coach or assess, but to walk alongside in the early months. Short check-ins, low threshold, high frequency. It shortens the learning loop and prevents a new manager from puzzling alone for too long over something that could be discussed in ten minutes.

The GROW model: structure for peer coaching

One of the most effective structures for peer coaching is the GROW model, developed by Sir John Whitmore. It gives managers a clear and easily applicable structure to coach each other. No vague conversations, but a focused dialogue.

The four steps in short.

  1. Goal. What do you really want to achieve in this question? A sharp formulation creates focus and prevents the group from drifting into side topics.
  2. Reality. What is actually happening? What have you already tried? What are facts and what are assumptions? This step prevents the group from offering solutions to a misunderstood situation.
  3. Opportunities. What options do we see together? This is where the strength of the peer team comes through. Multiple minds produce unexpected perspectives an individual manager would never have arrived at alone.
  4. Way forward. Which two concrete actions will you take? Not a list of ten. Two. Because without focused action, a good conversation stays nothing more than a good conversation.

The order is not optional. Anyone who jumps straight to options without sharpening goal and reality fills the time with ideas the person bringing in the case cannot place afterwards.

What changes when managers become a tribe

When a management layer starts to work this way, something shifts that you cannot always measure directly but can quickly feel. Managers carry less alone. Questions sharpen faster. Decisions get a second pair of eyes before they are executed. Mistakes are shared earlier rather than hidden.

Over time something develops that I call tribal belonging. A sense that you belong somewhere, not because of a title or a job description, but because of the people who carry the same things you do. For leaders who have made the transition into a management role, that is not a luxury. It is the foundation on which everything else can rest.

The effect then trickles down to the teams below. A management layer that itself functions well as a team models what it means to take colleagues seriously, to keep each other sharp and to ask for help before a problem grows large. What happens above becomes visible below.

The question I therefore ask every manager who feels stuck is the same question once asked of me. Who could you invite for coffee this week, just to talk, manager to manager?

A Take-Home Message

A promotion into management gives you a new role, but rarely a new team. That in-between space is not a personal failure but a structural gap in how organisations design promotions.

Treat managers as a peer team. Give them a rhythm of peer coaching with a simple structure such as GROW. What works well above becomes visible below.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do many new managers feel lonely after their promotion? +
A promotion to manager changes someone's social position within a single day. Former colleagues respond differently because the relationship has shifted. The new peer group, other managers, does not yet know the newcomer and is rarely organised as a group. As a result, the person lands in an in-between space. No longer part of the old team, not yet part of a new one. That phase often lasts months and is a key reason why the first year as a manager is heavy, even for people who are excellent at the substance of the role.
What is a peer coaching group and how is it different from a regular meeting? +
A peer coaching group is a fixed group of managers who coach each other at agreed moments using a clear process, for example the GROW model. A regular meeting is centred on information or decision making. A peer coaching group is centred on the case of an individual participant, and the group uses its different perspectives to help that participant move forward. The difference lies in the role distribution, the structure and the intent. Not talking about the organisation, but working on a question someone is carrying themselves.
What exactly is the GROW model? +
GROW is a coaching model developed by Sir John Whitmore and stands for Goal, Reality, Opportunities and Way forward. The person being coached first formulates a goal, then maps the current reality, explores possible options together with the group, and finally chooses two concrete actions. The strength lies in the order. By sharpening goal and reality first, you prevent the group from offering solutions to a poorly framed question.
How often should peer coaching groups meet to be effective? +
In practice, every two to four weeks works best, with sessions of sixty to ninety minutes. Less than an hour is usually too short for a serious GROW round. More than ninety minutes often leads to loss of focus. More important than the exact frequency is the regularity. A group that meets every other week and can rely on that consistently builds trust faster than a group that occasionally schedules a long session.
What if the manager has no time for a peer network? +
That is a common reaction and almost always a symptom of the problem itself. Managers who feel isolated solve more on their own than necessary, and therefore have less time. A peer network is not an extra activity alongside the work. It is a way to work faster and smarter because you no longer carry every question alone. The right question, then, is not 'do I have time for this', but 'what is it costing me to keep doing this alone'.
Raymond Honings
About the author

Raymond Honings

Raymond is the founder of Seemotion. He works with managers and leadership teams across cultures, helping them build self-reliant teams that perform under pressure. Over the past years he has worked with more than 1,000 managers worldwide. Today most of his work takes place in Asia, mainly in Korea, Taiwan, China and Japan.